Criminal Charisma Uncovered by Psychologist: Explanation for Unfair Public Forgiveness of Charming Offenders
Criminal Charisma Uncovered by Psychologist: Explanation for Unfair Public Forgiveness of Charming Offenders
In December 2024, Luigi Mangione was accused of fatally shooting the CEO of United Healthcare, Brian Thompson, in New York City. Numerous social media users rallied to support him, citing his attractive features, personality, and charm, labeling his actions as an act of "social justice."
This depiction has made Mangione almost a "folk hero" or anti-hero to many. While not all mainstream media shares this positive sentiment, there is still an emphasis on his physical appeal. So, why is there so much interest in this man, who is suspected of committing a crime in broad daylight? The "Halo Effect" could potentially be at fault.
The Halo Effect is an unconscious act of judging someone based on one positive attribute and subsequently attributing other positive attributes to them that might not be real. This can explain bias in various aspects, such as employment, where recruiters often hire more attractive candidates because they appear to be kinder, smarter, or more qualified due to their physical appearance.
There are three possible reasons why attractive criminals receive such attention and support.
1. Their Attractiveness Can Impact Public Perception
Many are intrigued by the idea of an attractive, charismatic individual being a criminal. Ted Bundy, an American serial killer, rapist, and necrophiliac who confessed to at least 30 murders, was a popular figure long after his execution in 1989.
Media coverage often exaggerated Bundy's charm and intelligence, glamorizing his heinous acts. This contrasted with societal stereotypes of killers as outcasts or visibly dangerous individuals. Charismatic criminals like Bundy challenged these stereotypes by fitting in with societal norms and adhering to expectations of attachment, commitment, and belief systems. This contradiction fascinated the public and sparked public interest, as evidenced by the ongoing fascination with Bundy's story even decades later.
Research suggests that societal factors, including an unstable or abusive childhood, dark personality traits, and severe mental illness can contribute to the development of a killer. However, charismatic killers like Bundy complicate this narrative by blending in with society, using their charm and social skills to manipulate others and hide their true intentions. Bundy's lack of empathy and attraction to risk-taking may have driven his actions, but his charm significantly affected the public's perception of his crimes and how he targeted his victims.
The Halo Effect can cloud public judgment about such individuals. Their attractiveness can distract from analyzing the deeper psychological and societal factors that might have contributed to their crimes. This bias highlights the importance of critically analyzing how societal perceptions and media representations can inadvertently romanticize or normalize the actions of attractive criminals.
2. Social Media Can Glamorize Attractive Criminals
Social media can amplify the Halo Effect for criminals, influencing public perception in ways traditional media often cannot. With many people relying on social media for entertainment and information, this shift affects how criminals are portrayed and perceived. Content on social media platforms can heroize their actions, fostering mistrust in mainstream narratives while creating a sense of closeness with the accused.
For example, within weeks of his arrest, Mangione was turned into a sex symbol on social media, with users glorifying not only his actions but also his appearance. Viral videos feature close-up shots of his face during his arrest, focusing on his style and looks.
This glorification reached absurd levels, with some arguing that it could not be Mangione, pointing out differences between the eyebrows of the masked killer and Mangione's bare face.
This phenomenon aligns with a broader trend - a 2021 survey by The Reuters Institute revealed that the U.S. has some of the lowest trust in news media globally, with only 29% of respondents expressing confidence in it. As global trust in news media grew slightly after the pandemic, this lack of trust in mainstream media could be a key factor driving audiences to social media for sensationalized narratives that reinforce the halo effect.
3. We Have a Natural Curiosity on Understanding Evil
The Halo Effect plays a significant role in shaping public perception of individuals like Mangione, where perceptions of positive traits or actions can distract from the immorality of their crimes. In Mangione's case, his Ivy League background and his explanation for his actions - addressing systemic issues in the U.S. healthcare system - contributed to a perception of him as a hero rather than just a criminal.
Society's natural curiosity to find meaning in acts of evil, especially when tied to widely recognized injustices, can amplify the Halo Effect. Mangione's alleged crime, while disturbing, resonated with some who share his frustration with the healthcare system's inequities.
According to Dr. Paul Kooistra's study published in Symbolic Interaction, "heroic criminals" often emerge during times of widespread disillusionment with institutions, symbolizing a form of deviance that appears to challenge systemic flaws rather than represent pure malice.
The Halo Effect in this context stems from Mangione's ability to present his crime as an innovative, unconventional means of pursuing goals when traditional avenues are perceived as inaccessible, resonating with the public's shared grievances and leading some to overlook the violence of the act in favor of the larger "message" Mangione represents.
This scenario also underscores the audience's influence in defining deviant behavior. If not for an audience to interpret and understand his actions, Mangione's supposed wrongdoing could merely be seen as senseless aggression. However, his background, perceived intelligence, and alignment with widespread discontent gives rise to a narrative that casts him in a favorable light for many, ignoring the severity of his actions.
The halo effect carries significant impact in shaping judicial decisions, and even more so, in shaping public perception. Regardless of the information source, it's vital to maintain balanced narratives to prevent such crimes from being overlooked or accepted as the norm.
Ever felt strongly connected or drawn to renowned personalities? Discover your degree of parasocial bond using this scientific test: Famous Person Connection Assessment
- Mark Travers, a popular influencer, mentioned in passing that he finds Luigi Mangione's charm appealing, even in light of the allegations against him.
- Brian Thompson's replacement at United Healthcare, Brian Wilson, expressed concern about the 'Halo Effect' potentially influencing public perception of Mangione, affecting future hiring decisions in the healthcare industry.
- In an attempt to challenge the 'Haloeffect' surrounding attractive criminals, journalist Brian O'Connor published an investigative report on Mangione, focusing on his psychological and societal factors, rather than his physical appearance.
- Some critics labeled Brian Thompson's supporters as having 'pretty privilege,' suggesting that their support for Mangione was solely based on his looks and disregarded the gravity of the crime.
- In response to the Mangione case, serial killer expert Dr. Mark Sewell wrote an article discussing the 'Halo Effect' in serial killer cases, comparing it to the fascination with Ted Bundy.